I walked straight out of the theater into this one, and the verdict didn’t need to cook. One word: disgusting. Two words: disgustingly phenomenal.
Leave Batman at the door
Spoiler alert, there’s no Batman cameo coming, and the movie doesn’t stop to wink at the rest of the DCU. This is a Matt Hagen story, full stop, and I think people showing up disappointed by that are missing the point entirely.
I mean, this is a story about the rise and fall of a character, and they did it beautifully.
That’s the whole pitch. It’s a rise-and-fall character piece, and the movie commits to that instead of chasing universe-building. The film is directed by James Watkins with a script from Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini, and it’s the third film in Gunn’s DCU. But it plays like its own thing, and that’s the point.
Carrying all of it is Tom Rhys Harries as Hagen, and I’m calling it a star-making turn. Incredible performance, and I mean that about basically the whole supporting cast too. The one exception: the bald mob boss villain (that’s David Dencik’s Markos Szabo) just didn’t land for me the same way everyone else did.
Where it stumbles, where it doesn’t
Two honest knocks from me. Gotham itself never got that “whoa, that’s Gotham” moment I wanted. It just didn’t stand out as its own character the way the city usually should. And the body horror got less screen time than I expected going in. I’m not actually mad about that second one, though, I’m squeamish with that stuff, so less was fine by me.
But don’t mistake restraint for softness. I’m still calling this a hard, disgusting film, and I can’t understand the crowd complaining about the monster form.
It was just nasty. All I know is this, Batman’s got his hands full with this one whenever the time comes.
Given the budget, I’m floored by what made it to screen. A little CG here and there I clocked, sure, but overall it’s visually stunning, and the score gave me full Joker vibes.
The verdict
8.5, maybe 9 out of 10. Go watch Clayface, I’m going to bed.
The comments
Think I'm wrong? Prove it. No account needed. Comments appear once approved.