Not all perfect reviews, but mostly good, and that’s enough to make history.
Not all perfect reviews, but mostly good.
The Score That Settles It
Clayface’s embargo lifted this week and critics mostly liked it. The film debuted “Fresh” and climbed to “Certified Fresh,” earning a 75% score on Rotten Tomatoes from 83 reviews following the lifting of its review embargo on October 21, 2026. That puts it comfortably between the 83% “fresh” score for 2025’s Superman and the 52% “rotten” score for 2026’s Supergirl, right where you’d want to land as DC’s weird horror swing of the year.
But here’s the number that actually matters: Clayface has debuted as the highest-rated solo Batman villain movie to date, currently sitting at 74%. And it’s not just clearing the DC bar. That puts it above both Joker movies, Joker at 68% and Joker: Folie à Deux at 31%, and well above the 2004 Catwoman movie’s 8%.
Zoom out to Marvel’s side of the ledger and it’s not close. Sony’s entire Spider-Man villain slate, the movies built around characters like Spider-Man’s rogues gallery without Spider-Man in them, never even cracked “fresh.” Venom topped out around 30%, Venom: Let There Be Carnage got as high as 58%, and Morbius, Madame Web, and Kraven the Hunter all landed in the 11%-to-17% range. Clayface at 75% isn’t just a good DC movie. It’s the best-reviewed comic book villain solo film either company has released, period.
Why Critics Split
The score isn’t unanimous, and it shouldn’t be treated like one. William Bibbiani of The Wrap called it “a decent monster movie, with all the straightforward entertainment value that comes with telling a story about a wet pile of gelatinous flesh that kills people.” On the other side, Kate Erbland of IndieWire knocked “the uneven nature of the film, its plotting, its character motivations” as the reviews got bloodier the longer the movie runs. That split is exactly why 75% feels right instead of inflated, it’s a movie with real fans and real detractors, not a consensus hit coasting on vibes.
The Box Office Number Nobody Agrees On
Here’s the fact-check: projections for Clayface’s opening weekend have genuinely ranged from $15 million up to $35 million depending on who you ask. Variety had it at $25 million to $35 million, Boxoffice Pro forecasted $25 million to $30 million, and Box Office Theory’s most recent read came in lower at $15 million to $23 million. So no, there isn’t one agreed-upon number, but the spread does run almost exactly $15M to $35M, which makes it one of the widest tracking gaps of the year for a studio release.
What tightens that gap is the reviews. A movie that’s “Certified Fresh” and now holds the best critical score of any DC or Marvel villain movie ever made has a real shot at landing on the higher end of that range once word of mouth kicks in this weekend.
The comments
Think I'm wrong? Prove it. No account needed. Comments appear once approved.